Choosing between a fixed-rate and a tracker mortgage is one of the biggest decisions you’ll make when arranging a mortgage. It affects your monthly payments, your flexibility and how exposed you are if interest rates change. The honest answer is that neither is automatically better. The right choice depends on your budget, your plans and how comfortable you are with uncertainty. Here’s how to weigh them up.
Fixed vs Tracker at a Glance
| Fixed-rate mortgage | Tracker mortgage | |
|---|---|---|
| Interest rate | Stays the same for the whole deal period | Follows the Bank of England base rate, plus a set margin |
| Monthly payments | Predictable | Can go up or down |
| If rates rise | You’re protected until the deal ends | Your payments rise |
| If rates fall | You don’t benefit until the deal ends | Your payments fall |
| Early repayment charges | Usually apply during the fixed period | Often lower or none, but not guaranteed |
| Best for | Certainty and budgeting | Flexibility and willingness to accept some risk |
What Is a Fixed-Rate Mortgage?
With a fixed-rate mortgage, your interest rate stays the same for an agreed period, so your monthly payment doesn’t change whatever happens to interest rates. Typical fixed periods are two, three, five or ten years. When the deal ends, you normally move onto your lender’s standard variable rate unless you remortgage or switch to a new deal.
Advantages
- Predictable payments make budgeting simple
- You’re protected if interest rates rise
- Peace of mind, especially if your budget is tight
Disadvantages
- You won’t benefit if rates fall during the fix
- Early repayment charges usually apply if you leave early
- Fixed rates can sometimes be priced higher than trackers
What Is a Tracker Mortgage?
A tracker mortgage follows another rate, usually the Bank of England base rate, plus a set margin. For example, a tracker priced at base rate plus 1% will always be one percentage point above the base rate. When the base rate changes, your rate changes by the same amount.
Advantages
- Your payments fall if the base rate falls
- Often has lower early repayment charges, or none
- Can suit people who may move, overpay or remortgage in the near future
Disadvantages
- Your payments rise if the base rate rises
- Harder to budget with, because payments can change
- Some trackers do carry early repayment charges, so always check
What a Rate Change Could Mean for Your Payments
Here’s an illustration for a £200,000 repayment mortgage over 25 years. The rates are examples to show the effect, not current market rates.
| Interest rate | Approximate monthly payment |
|---|---|
| 3.5% | £1,001 |
| 4.5% | £1,112 |
| 5.5% | £1,228 |
In this example, a one-point rise from 4.5% to 5.5% adds about £116 a month, while a one-point fall would reduce payments by around £110 a month. That’s the trade-off in a nutshell: a tracker passes both the benefit and the risk on to you, while a fixed rate keeps your payment steady.
Early Repayment Charges
An early repayment charge (ERC) is a fee for leaving or overpaying beyond your allowance before the deal ends. On fixed-rate deals, ERCs often range from about 1% to 5% of the amount you repay, usually reducing as the deal goes on. On a £200,000 mortgage, a 3% charge would be £6,000, so it’s worth knowing before you commit.
Trackers often have lower ERCs, or none, which is part of their appeal. But this isn’t guaranteed, so check the terms of any deal you’re considering.
Other Types of Variable Rate
- Standard variable rate (SVR): your lender’s default rate, which can change at any time and is often higher than a deal rate. Most people move onto it automatically when a fixed or tracker deal ends
- Discount mortgage: a discount off the lender’s SVR for a set period, so your payments still move if the SVR changes
- Lifetime tracker: follows the base rate for the entire mortgage term, not just an initial period
Which Is Better for You?
A fixed rate may suit you if:
- You have a tight monthly budget and want certainty
- You’d struggle if payments rose
- You plan to stay in the property for the length of the fix
- You value peace of mind over potential savings
A tracker may suit you if:
- You have some financial flexibility if payments rise
- You might move, overpay or remortgage in the next few years
- You want lower early repayment charges
- You’re comfortable with some uncertainty
First-Time Buyers
First-time buyers often choose a fixed rate because budgets tend to be stretched and certainty helps while you’re getting used to new costs. But a tracker can work if you have a cushion and want flexibility. Our [first-time buyer mortgage guide] covers the wider process.
Remortgaging
When your deal ends, you can choose a fixed rate, a tracker or another product. If you might move or pay off a chunk of the loan soon, a tracker with low or no ERCs can be worth a look. If you want to lock in certainty, a fixed rate may suit better. Our guide to [remortgaging in the UK] explains the process.
Can You Switch From a Tracker to a Fixed Rate?
Many lenders allow you to move from a tracker to a fixed rate, and because trackers often have low or no ERCs, it can often be done without a large penalty. However, the fixed rates available when you switch may be higher or lower than today’s, so don’t assume you can lock in today’s prices later. Always check your terms first.
Can Anyone Predict Which Will Be Cheaper?
No. Nobody can reliably predict interest rates. Lenders price fixed rates based on where they expect rates to go, which is why a tracker can look cheaper or dearer at different times. Rather than trying to guess the market, think about what you can afford if payments rose, and how much certainty you want.
Questions to Ask Yourself Before Choosing
- Could I afford the payments if rates rose by one or two percentage points?
- How long do I expect to stay in this property?
- Might I want to overpay or pay off a lump sum?
- How much do I value certainty over potential savings?
- What are the early repayment charges, and could I afford them?
- What will the deal revert to when it ends?
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a fixed or tracker mortgage better?
Neither is automatically better. A fixed rate offers certainty, while a tracker offers flexibility and the possibility of lower payments if rates fall. The right choice depends on your circumstances.
Are tracker mortgages cheaper than fixed rates?
Sometimes, but not always. It depends on the lender, the loan-to-value, fees and the market at the time, so compare the full cost, not just the headline rate.
Do tracker mortgages have early repayment charges?
Many have lower charges or none, but some do, so check the terms of each deal.
What happens to a tracker mortgage if the base rate goes up?
Your interest rate rises by the same amount, so your monthly payments go up.
How long should I fix my mortgage for?
Common fixes are two, three, five and ten years. A longer fix gives certainty for longer but may mean paying an early repayment charge if you leave. A broker can help you weigh this up.
Can I overpay on a fixed-rate mortgage?
Most lenders let you overpay up to a set limit each year without a charge, often around 10% of the balance. Going over it can trigger an early repayment charge.
Not sure whether a fixed or tracker mortgage is right for you? Speak to our team for free, no-obligation advice, with no broker fee.
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.